Cart 0


Are you ready for Spring? Join our mailing list and enjoy 15% off of all online orders.

from $18 buy New York's best pie shipped or pickup from our Main Street Chatham, NY bakery!

Backyard Apple Pie_1.jpg

Baked to Perfection

Handwrought pies, cookies, muffins, tartes and an entire range of baked goods created with love the old fashioned way with only the best, all natural Hudson Valley ingredients. No preservatives. No shortcuts, ever.

We love what we do! Each & every pie and bakery item we create is as unique as the beautiful people who enjoy them. 


Quality Ingredients

We work closely with local farms & suppliers to source natural, wholesome products.

Our recipes are made with nature in mind.  The best pies and other baked goods are created from tart apples, rich maple syrup and free range chicken eggs.

The pie and bakery menu continuously changes as we mix up new ideas and get creative.


Taking one of our pies home could not be easier.  If you live near our store in Chatham, New York come on by!  Otherwise we can deliver fresh to your door by placing an order here.  How easy is that?


Available for store pick up or mail order

Follow us on Instagram @pieconicny