Proudly baking on Main Street

Chatham, NY

Our home cafe, Main St Goodness is now open for Breakfast all day, lunch, coffee & more!

Summer 2019 hours

Sun 8a to 5p

Mon 8a to 6p

Tue 8a to 6p

Wed 8a to 6p

Thu 8a - 6p

Fri 8a - 7p

Sat 8a - 7p


We bake 7 days for online orders and will always open the doors for your pie pick-up!

PieconicNY LLC

Located inside Main St Goodness cafe

20 Main Street

Chatham, NY 12037-1203



Baking iconic pies just off the last stop of the Taconic Parkway in New York's bucolic upper Hudson Valley full of the delicious farm fresh stuff that goes in each pie.